On November 20, 2026, the International Nuremberg Principles Academy is hosting a dialogue on the continuing relevance of the Nuremberg Principles. Weeks earlier, legal experts published a new commentary examining unlawful orders and individual responsibility. The date also marks 81 years since the Nuremberg Trials began.
That question has a human face. In a Reuters report published November 19, an Iranian teacher known as Shirin described being wounded by gunfire during the January 2026 crackdown, part of the violence documented in the timeline of Iran’s protests.
When security forces unlawfully attack civilians, who bears responsibility: those who fire, those who give the orders, or both?
For Nick Berg, whose life connects resistance in revolutionary Iran with later U.S. Special Operations service, this question reaches beyond international law into duty, loyalty and conscience.
Sources:
Nuremberg Academy Dialogue: The United Nations and the Nuremberg Principles — November 20, 2026
Case Western Reserve University — Editorial Staff Experts at CWRU School of Law’s Nuremberg: Conference Pen a Modern Commentary to the Nuremberg Principles — October 28, 2026
John Davison, Reuters: An Iranian Teacher Bared Her Life to the World. She Didn’t Tell a Soul at Home. — November 19, 2026
What Did the Nuremberg Principles Establish About Following Orders?
The Nuremberg Principles established that individuals can be held responsible for crimes under international law even when acting on government or superior orders, provided a genuine moral choice was possible.
During the Nuremberg Trials, senior Nazi officials faced charges including crimes against peace, war crimes and crimes against humanity. Article 8 of the International Military Tribunal’s Charter rejected following orders as an automatic defense, although such orders could be considered when determining punishment.
In 1946, the United Nations General Assembly affirmed the legal principles established at Nuremberg. Four years later, the International Law Commission formulated seven principles, including Principle IV, which explicitly addressed obedience to superior orders.
The crucial qualification was whether a moral choice had been possible. This meant examining whether an individual had a genuine opportunity to act differently, rather than assuming that everyone operating within a command structure had the same freedom to choose.
The distinction was fundamental. Military rank, government authority and institutional loyalty could not automatically shield someone from responsibility for international crimes. But determining that responsibility also required consideration of the circumstances in which an individual acted.
Sources:
Memorium Nuremberg Trials — City of Nuremberg: Birth of International Criminal Law
United Nations, International Law Commission: Principles of International Law Recognized in the Charter of the Nürnberg Tribunal and in the Judgment of the Tribunal — 1950
Can Soldiers Refuse Orders That Violate International Law?
Military discipline requires obedience to lawful orders, but it does not provide unlimited protection when an order requires conduct prohibited by international law. Soldiers have a duty to refuse orders that are manifestly unlawful.
The distinction matters. A lawful order must be followed, while a questionable instruction may require clarification. But an order to deliberately shoot peaceful, unarmed protesters crosses a different line. Obedience cannot automatically excuse such violence.
Military training reinforces discipline, trust and loyalty within a chain of command. These qualities are essential when decisions must be made under pressure, as explored in how military training shapes resilience. Yet they can also make challenging a superior’s instructions difficult.
Article 33 of the Rome Statute allows a limited defense for following superior orders, but only under specific conditions: a legal obligation to obey, lack of knowledge that the order was unlawful, and an order that was not manifestly unlawful. Orders to commit genocide or crimes against humanity are explicitly considered manifestly unlawful.
Military responsibility therefore involves more than obedience. It also requires recognizing its legal limits.
Sources:
European Union Agency for Asylum (EUAA): 6.2. Superior Orders — Interpretation and Application of Exclusion Grounds in International Protection, 2026
What Do the Nuremberg Principles Reveal About Iran's Protest Killings?
The Nuremberg Principles offer a framework for examining individual responsibility for international crimes, but applying them to Iran’s protest killings requires evidence of each person’s conduct, knowledge and involvement.
Iran’s demonstrations began on December 28, 2025. On January 8 and 9, security forces opened fire on protesters and bystanders across the country, killing thousands. Amnesty International identified units of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), including Basij battalions, police divisions and plainclothes agents among those involved.
Human Rights Watch interviewed witnesses and examined 51 verified photographs and videos, documenting gunshot injuries, bodies at morgues and shootings across multiple provinces. These findings reveal widespread violence, but do not establish every individual’s responsibility.
On September 21, the UN’s Independent International Fact-Finding Mission reported that many violations during the crackdown amounted to crimes against humanity, including murder, imprisonment and torture.
The distinction matters. Violence against protesters is primarily assessed under international human rights law and standards governing law enforcement. Crimes against humanity may also apply when their legal requirements are met. Such acts are not automatically war crimes.
The central question is therefore not simply who participated in the crackdown, but what evidence can establish individual responsibility for the crimes committed?
Sources:
Amnesty International: What Happened at the Protests in Iran? — 2026
Human Rights Watch: Iran: Growing Evidence of Countrywide Massacres — January 16, 2026
United Nations Office at Geneva — Sara Hossain, Chair of the Independent International Fact-Finding Mission on Iran: HRC 63 – Human Rights in Iran — September 21, 2026
Who Is Responsible for Unlawful Orders: The Officer or the Commander?
Responsibility for unlawful orders can extend to both direct perpetrators and their superiors, depending on their actions, authority, knowledge and failure to prevent or punish crimes.
This distinction is central to command responsibility. Article 28 of the Rome Statute establishes that military commanders may be criminally responsible for crimes committed by forces under their effective control when their failure to exercise that control properly contributes to the crimes. They must have known, or should have known, what was happening and failed to take necessary and reasonable measures to prevent, suppress or report the crimes.
Effective control matters more than rank alone. A commander must have had the practical authority to influence subordinates’ conduct. A senior title does not automatically establish criminal responsibility.
Investigators therefore examine operational orders, communications, witness testimony and reporting structures. These can help establish what commanders knew, when they knew it and whether they had opportunities to intervene.
Nick Berg explores the importance of restraint and accountability in special operations leadership. International criminal law examines a more specific question: did those in command have the knowledge and authority to prevent crimes, and did they fail to act?
Sources:
International Criminal Court (ICC): Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court — Article 28: Responsibility of Commanders and Other Superiors — July 17, 1998
Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute: Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, Article 28 — gebaseerd op het Statuut van 1998
What Does Nick Berg's Experience Reveal About Duty and Conscience?
Nick Berg’s experiences during Iran’s revolution and his later service in U.S. Special Operations offer two perspectives on the relationship between authority, loyalty and individual conscience. His life raises an important distinction: respecting military discipline is not the same as surrendering personal judgment.
Growing up in revolutionary Iran, Berg witnessed the consequences of political power becoming increasingly restrictive. Rather than accepting the new regime’s authority, he became involved in resistance, eventually fleeing the country after an execution order was issued against him.
His experience with military authority was particularly complex. In a 2025 interview with Walk With History, Berg recalled being taken from the street into the Iranian army during the Iran-Iraq War. Years later, he joined the U.S. Army, eventually serving in Special Operations. He described finding structure, belonging and purpose through his American military service.
These experiences inform Nick Berg’s personal journey and the fictional character Ricardo in Shadows of Tehran. Ricardo’s struggle with authority, betrayal and survival reflects the difficult choices faced by people whose lives are shaped by political conflict.
Berg’s story does not establish how he would respond to any particular unlawful order. It does, however, highlight a distinction central to this discussion: loyalty may be essential to military service, but loyalty and moral responsibility are not always the same thing.
Why Is Accountability for Protest Killings So Difficult?
Accountability for protest killings is difficult because investigators must establish individual responsibility through reliable evidence, while restricted access, political interference and jurisdictional barriers can obstruct justice.
In Iran, communication blackouts and restrictions on independent investigations have complicated efforts to preserve testimony, verify evidence and identify those responsible. Even when investigators establish patterns of violence, connecting specific crimes to individual perpetrators requires evidence that can withstand legal scrutiny.
A United Nations fact-finding report can document violations and preserve evidence, but it cannot convict or sentence those responsible.
International prosecution presents another obstacle. Iran is not a party to the Rome Statute, meaning the International Criminal Court does not automatically have jurisdiction over crimes committed within its territory.
National courts may offer an alternative. In August 2026, Human Rights Activists in Iran submitted evidence to German prosecutors seeking an investigation under Germany’s universal-jurisdiction laws. However, requesting an investigation does not guarantee prosecution.
The Nuremberg Principles established that individuals can be held accountable. Ensuring that accountability becomes reality remains a different challenge.
Sources:
United Nations Human Rights Council: Human Rights Council Adopts Resolution Extending Mandates of Fact-Finding Mission and Special Rapporteur on Iran — January 23, 2026.
Human Rights Watch: Questions and Answers: US, Israel, Iran, and the Laws of War — April 8, 2026
Iran International: Iran Rights Group Seeks German Probe Into Crimes Against Humanity — September 3, 2026
Do the Nuremberg Principles Still Matter Today?
The Nuremberg Principles remain relevant because responsibility for international crimes cannot automatically be hidden behind government authority or military orders. But their real test comes after the wrongdoing has been documented.
Iran’s protest killings expose the distance between recognizing a legal principle and enforcing it. Evidence must be preserved, responsibility established and credible courts given an opportunity to act. Without those steps, the language of accountability risks becoming a promise that victims never see fulfilled.
Eighty-one years after the Nuremberg Trials began, the question is no longer only whether following orders can be challenged.
It is whether governments and international institutions are willing to pursue accountability when doing so becomes politically difficult.















